YES, you can still find them useful. So much that you may never look back once you tried.
NO, you do not need the whole assortment available, me neither, but a few tools can make all the differences in your work precision.
As a minimum I would say 3
A jack, with a spare blade assembly, a router plane and a rabbet or shoulder plane
Lets have a closer look
Jack plane
When you work with hand tools, you would use three bench planes, The Jack, the Jointer and finally the Smoother, to take a board from rough to finish surface. The three Amigos
Since we are not flattening board by hands but just mostly trimming them, the lonely Jack can do it all with one spare blade assembly.
Get your hands on a good old Stanley No 5 Jack plane or its numerous clones There are everywhere in yard sales, flea markets, Kijiji etc. Don't worry about rust, unless severely pitted will come out plenty good to be a good worker. Price? Expect to pay anywhere from $5 to $25 for what would become a good worker after some work. Nothing too seriously wrong with them. Worth all the trousers ruined with the WD-40 and rust stains :-)
Why two blades? One shaped with a curvature of about 8 inch radius, act like a scrub plane to quickly remove material to flatten boards which are too wide for the jointer and the spare blade keep straight with the corners slightly relieved, act like a smoother and a jointer. One plane does the work of three.
Why getting a premium spare blade set? Because if nothing else, it will transform your tool into a real good one, and show you what to expect from a properly sharpen and set up blade. Worth every penny.
But you don't have to go this way, you can get New Old Stock blade (look at Bargain Harley's in Berwick) or just a new spare cutter from a hardware store. Just don't expect them to work as good as the premium stuff. Not without some fettling anyway.
It size and mass also makes it a very good plane to use on a shooting board.
You can easily and effortlessly shaves off a few thou's of wood repeatedly, safely.
Impossible with any power tools. The closest would be a disk sander, but not as precise and harder on the fingers :-)
I will show you how to build and use it. If you have a plane, you need one.
Router plane
If you do any kind of joinery involving Dados, Rabbets, Tenons, or want to clean up to a level surface a recess opening. You need a router plane.
Think your dadoes are coming off clean off the table saw? NOPE, take a look at the bottom surface.
Think it does not matter? It will prevent your pieces from fully seating, causing distortions.
It is probably filled with small ridges left over from dadoes blades and spacers. The depth is a bit uneven by inconsistent down pressure when your piece was passing over the dado head while cutting. Yes, you can minimized that by using feather boards, but it may still be uneven. Not to mention if there was any curvature in your workpiece, it is not going to cut evenly.
Using a router table (as in electric screaming router) will produce the same inconsistencies in depth. Minimized with feather boards, almost taking care of when using a power feeder. But there is an easier way...
The Stanley No 71 Router plane
The router plane riding on the surrounding top surface ensure an even bottom cut. Need a wider base for your router? Notice the 2 holes in the bottom? That is to attach a wood piece of whatever length you need to bridge the opening.
They comes in three sizes Small, Medium and Large.
Stanley and others only made two sizes: The large one No 71 and the small one No 271
The largest (No 71) is your most used. It in turn comes with three cutters: Square across (in two width) and a spear point cutter. Shown on my LV router pic above.
I used practically all the time, my spear point cutter. Goes in everywhere, can attack the grain at various angles.
Note that the large Veritas one can use the older Stanley No 71 cutters and vice versa. So If you find an old one with missing cutters, you can buy new ones at LV.
The rabbet plane or the shoulder plane.
Both may look similar, blade extending on both side of sole, unlike your typical bench plane, both they are different animals.
I used them interchangeably in this example, because either could do the other's job, albeit not as good, due to the different bed angle.
Why would you need one? Again for quick clean up of your power tool joinery, or even to cut the rabbets quicker than it will take you to set up the dado head, make your cuts then take it all out again for storage. And you may still need clean up the joinery. So yeah, it's handy to have.
If going for a rabbet plane, one very versatile model is the Stanley No 78 Duplex, Fillester plane
It is a Bullnose plane or a Rabbet plane (Duplex) and a Fillester plane (with the fence)
To be considered complete, it should come with the fence and the depth stop. There is only one blade with it. You either use it up front (bull nose ) or in the back as a rabbet plane.
Its weakest point is how the fence attach to the single rod, with a thumb screw.
NO matter how hard you cinch it (Please do not use a pair of pliers) that damn fence will droop, meaning it is now a smidgen loose. Just think of the fence and the depth stops as "suggesters" rather than definite stops. Don't be a Cro-Magnon and everything will be fine, watch your layout lines and stop before you blow by them.
Expect to pay about $50 and up, depending on condition and if complete.. Buying missing parts will cost you as much as you pay for the tool, no real bargain. The depth "suggester" you can easily do without. The fence, I rarely use, so ...
The Record No 778 is an improved version of this plane, using two rods for the fence. Depth stop remains a depth suggester (as in most planes BTW) rather than a stop, but the fence problem is fixed.
A new more precise metal plane would be a premium skew rabbet plane from Veritas
If going for a wooden Rabbet plane, get a skew version, it will handle straight grain and end grain better. Prices about $15-30 range used. Depend on name, condition etc.
If going for a Shoulder plane get the largest you an afford, I.E. at least 3/4 inch and above
If buying new, cannot say enough good things for the Veritas shoulder planes,
OR, since we already have our trusty 1/2 in chisel, sharp and ready to go, why not transform it into a rabbet plane?
Don't panic, nothing complicated Watch how it is done...using saw and chisels... Which you should have by now.
Rehabbing and using antiques wooden rabbet planes? Watch this
If you been following along your tool kit should now looks something like this.
And we are almost done. Next we will add a few essential marking and measuring tools, and then you are all set.
Yes, you will find most of these tools at the Wood Hobby shop, but you are better off having your own. They will be always available to you, sharper, and you will avoid measurements errors by using the same tool throughout your project.
Not a big kit to carry around and maximize your shop time.
Bob, the tools peddler
No arguments for me as I agree with all you said.
ReplyDeleteThanks Ralph. This is shaping up as my most minimalist list ever :-)
ReplyDeleteBob
Bob,
ReplyDeleteFun read, but I will bet not easy to write.
ken
You are so right Ken. So many tools I want to put in...must resist... :-)
ReplyDeleteTruly is my most minimalist tool kit I ever put together :-)
Bob, working on last one, marking & measuring
I agree with what you say. The only essential planes I see missing are a plough plane and a spoke shave. Maybe a machine tool woodworker can do without but I'd bet times these two would be handy to have.
ReplyDeleteLarge shoulder planes are really heavy. I'm surprised with some of your audience so close to retirement that they can lift them.
ReplyDeleteI bought a couple of large ones, a 1-1/8 and 1-1/4 and find them unwieldy. My usual advice of putting a piece of wood underneath doesn't apply since tenon shoulders are much smaller.
If I saw a 1/2" one I would snap it up and it would likely be my go-to.
Add an audio device to fill the silence that power woodworkers don't experience.